2025 Fantasy Football: Top Tight End Prospects
Tyler Warren, Penn State
Warren had a limited role in his first four seasons at Penn State, catching 49 passes for 606 yards and 11 touchdowns. In 2024, he emerged as the centerpiece of the offense, leading tight ends with 104 receptions, 1,233 yards, and 8 touchdowns. He also contributed to the run game (26 carries, 218 yards, and 4 TDs) and completed 3 of 6 passes for 35 yards and 1 TD. Warren had a standout game against USC (17/228/1) and two other 100+ yard performances (@Purdue: 8/130/2 and @Minnesota: 8/102). He recorded 6+ catches in 10 of 16 starts.
At 6’6” and 260 lbs., Warren wins contested catches, excels in short and intermediate routes, and shows speed and open-field running. His blocking is adequate for quick runs but needs improvement against elite pass rushers in the NFL. Comparable to Travis Kelce, Warren projects as a first-round pick with significant growth potential. His fantasy value in 2025 will depend on his NFL landing spot, where he could quickly become a focal point.
Colston Loveland, Michigan
Colston Loveland caught 117 passes for 1,466 yards and 11 touchdowns over 39 games at Michigan. In 2024, he set career highs with 56 receptions and 5 touchdowns but averaged 10.4 yards per catch, down from 14.4 in 2023. His best game was against Oregon (7/112). A shoulder injury sidelined him for the final three games, but he had 6+ catches in 6 of 10 games.
At 6’5” and 245 lbs., Loveland plays physically with strong hands and finds short-area openings. His agility allows him to exploit coverage gaps deep, though his release off the line needs work for early NFL wins. His blocking struggles against larger defenders in pass protection, and his route tempo requires refinement. Michigan’s low-volume passing game (23.9 attempts per game) limited his ceiling, but the NFL should offer more opportunities. Similar to Tyler Warren in many areas, Loveland trails in open-field ability. He’s a likely first-round pick, possibly to the Chargers (22nd overall) due to his Jim Harbaugh connection.
Mason Taylor, LSU
Mason Taylor caught 129 passes for 1,308 yards and 6 touchdowns over 38 games at LSU, gaining 10.1 yards per catch. In 2024, he improved to 55 receptions for 546 yards and 2 touchdowns, ranking third in LSU’s receiving production in a pass-heavy offense (534 attempts). He turns 21 in May 2025, offering a developmental edge.
At 6’5” and 255 lbs., with a 4.65 40-yard dash and 28 bench press reps, Taylor uses speed and quickness to beat linebackers. His hands are reliable in tight quarters, but his route tempo and blocking fire need work. His route-running lacks polish, relying on athleticism over technique. Taylor projects as a high-upside tight end, potentially for the Chiefs if they trade up. A first- or second-round pick, his NFL growth will benefit from coaching and experience.
Elijah Arroyo, Miami
Elijah Arroyo had minimal production in his first three seasons at Miami (11/163/1) due to injuries, including a 2022 right ACL tear. In 2024, he caught 35 passes for 590 yards and 7 touchdowns, averaging 16.9 yards per catch. His best games included 4/89, 6/79, 5/44/1, and 4/64/1.
At 6’4” and 235 lbs., Arroyo’s frame resembles a big wide receiver. His release and route-running are underdeveloped, and his blocking needs improvement. However, he excels after the catch, showing elusiveness and speed when given space past the second level. Lingering knee issues led him to opt out of the NFL Combine, impacting his draft stock. Without injury concerns, Arroyo would be a high-upside pick for teams with strong quarterback and receiver play. He projects as a Day 3 pick with limited early fantasy relevance but long-term potential if he stays healthy.
Thomas Fidone, Nebraska
Thomas Fidone had a limited role at Nebraska, catching 25 passes for 260 yards and 4 touchdowns in 2023 and 36 passes for 373 yards in 2024. Nebraska’s offense averaged 33.4 pass attempts in 2024, limiting his opportunities. He had three 50+ yard games (6/91, 4/55, and 5/50). A 2021 left ACL tear and subsequent surgery cost him two seasons.
At 6’6” and 240 lbs., with a 4.70 40-yard dash, Fidone’s speed ranks among the top tight ends. His blocking is adequate but needs strength to handle NFL defenders. His route-running foundation is strong, with speed to threaten deep, though he labors in change-of-direction moves. Nebraska targeted him past the second level, where he found open space. He lacks elusiveness after the catch. Fidone’s injury history will lower his draft stock, but his recovery signals upside. A Day 3 pick, he’s a developmental prospect with a chance to contribute down the road.